Sunday, February 23, 2014

Adventure of the Empty Twisted Lip with a Case of a Creeping Carbuncle with a Reigate Interpreter

Yes, you read that right

Whilst on vacation  a business trip last weekend, I found myself with some time to kill and free Wi-fi.  So, being the anglophile I am, and finding myself with unexpected quiet time, I endured the interminable Admiral Cruise Lines ads and watched the first episode of the third season of Sherlock: "The Empty Hearse."

I was pleasantly surprised; after last season left me a little undersatisfied (and a wee bit disturbed), "The Empty Hearse" just worked:
  • The interplay between Sherlock and Molly was very well done - after last year's awkardness.
  • Very happy with the casting for Mary Morstan; Amanda Abbingdon shone in the role, and her real-life relationship with Martin Freeman gives the couple a playfulness that rather humanizes John a bit...
  • ...but incredibly glad to see the damned mustache go.  It was funny for an in-joke, but there were plenty of those already.


"From your mustache, I can deduce that you are single."
"Why, what, er, from the shape or, er, something?"
"What?  No, because it's ugly."

  • Loved the overload of Doyle references throughout; I summarize the ones I picked up in the title; I'm sure there are more.
  • The "Blue Carbuncle" reference was the best of that lot; "A Case of Identity" was the most subtly wonderful.
  • It would've killed 'em to drop a blue Police Box into the background somewhere?  No lingering shot, no offhand remarks, just a drive-by on Fleet St. or somewhere.  Truly overload ever Beeb-addict in the world's head in one shot.

So what'd I really think?

Glad to see the franchise back and at fighting weight.  Exclusive of Episode 1, last season just did not work for me.  I thought they totally missed the feel of "Baskervilles," (although they get mad props for even trying to update that one), and the ending was too abrupt, too cold - directed by Moriarty, not Watson.  It was the suicide sequence, of course - those always get me - but nonetheless, I walked away gladly and haven't rewatched them since.



Oh, shut up.  Everybody has an off year.

For context, I rewatched Series 1 four times in the first two weeks I had the DVD's.

The team got it back with this episode.  Sherlock should be almost uproariously funny at times - Doyle's detective had a rapier wit and classic Victorian timing - and Freeman's furious response to Cumberbatch's reincarnated Holmes is what Doyle would be writing if he were still at it today (and weren't well over 100 years old, that is.)

Rating: Go watch it.  Now.  



No comments:

Post a Comment